20 replies to this topic

[ThinkInvisible]

The code

Select Case variable
  case value0
    code
  case value1
    code
  etc.
  case else
    code

in .NET is used to do things based on a variable instead of using lots of if structures. Is there anything like this in Lua?

[Lettuce]

I'm... sorry. I don't understand your question. I've never worked with .NET, so I'm unsure what you are going for here. Could you tell me what sort of program you are writing? I'm assuming you mean something like conditional statements, but I (or probably anyone, for that matter) don't know what you need without more detail.
If I can help you, I will. But even if I can't, a bit more description means someone else might.

[ThinkInvisible]

This (VB.Net):

Select Case daynumber 'we are testing the variable "daynumber"
  case 0 'is it zero?
	dayname = "Monday" 'do this if so
  case 1 'or is it one?
	dayname = "Tuesday" 'then do this
  case 2 'and so on
	dayname = "Wednesday"
  case 3
	dayname = "Thursday"
  case 4
	dayname = "Friday"
  case 5, 6 'is it five OR six?
	dayname = "Weekend!" 'then do this
  case else 'did all of the above fail?
	print("Error: invalid number.") 'then do these
	dayname = "What?"
end select 'stop testing the variable

is equivalent to this (lua):

if daynumber == 0 then
  dayname = "Monday"
elseif daynumber == 1 then
  dayname = "Tuesday"
elseif daynumber == 2 then
  dayname = "Wednesday"
elseif daynumber == 3 then
  dayname = "Thursday"
elseif daynumber == 4 then
  dayname = "Friday"
elseif daynumber == 5 or daynumber == 6 then
  dayname = "Weekend!"
else
  print("Error: invalid number.")
  dayname = "What?"
end

so it's mostly organization.

[Lettuce]

After running several trials to see if I could shorten that, the best I found was to try a table:

Spoiler

name = {"Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday"}
while true do
    print "What day is it?"
    daynumber = io.read()
    daynumber = tonumber(daynumber)
        if daynumber == 1 then
        print "It is" print(name[1])
        elseif daynumber == 2 then
        print "It is" print(name[2])
        elseif daynumber == 3 then
        print "It is" print(name[3])
        elseif daynumber == 4 then
        print "It is" print(name[4])
        elseif daynumber == 5 then
        print "It is" print(name[5])
        elseif daynumber == 6 or daynumber == 7 then
        print "It's a weekend! Hooray!"
        else
        print "Where do you live?"
        end
end

That looks a bit cleaner.
I should really use tables more often, they are quite useful. For an in-depth guide on them, check the ComputerCraft wiki.
Hope that helps.
-- Lettuce

[ardera]

I know what you mean, in JAVA there is something like this too, but lua hasn't this feature... I think its added in 5.2 but Im not sure... (CC uses 5.1)

[Lettuce]

Found an even better way. Still using tables, shortened last post to 11 lines. Previously it was 21.

Spoiler

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
    print "What day is it?"
    daynumber = io.read()
    daynumber = tonumber(daynumber)
        if daynumber == 0 or daynumber >= 8 then
        print "Where do you live?!"
        else
        print "It is" print(name[daynumber])
        end
end

That's as clean as you're gonna get it in Lua.

[kreezxil]

Lettuce, on 27 August 2012 - 06:16 PM, said:

Found an even better way. Still using tables, shortened last post to 11 lines. Previously it was 21.

Spoiler

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	daynumber = io.read()
	daynumber = tonumber(daynumber)
	if daynumber == 0 or daynumber >= 8 then
		print "Where do you live?!"
	else
		print "It is" print(name[daynumber])
	end
end

That's as clean as you're gonna get it in Lua.

10 Lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
    print "What day is it?"
    daynumber = tonumber(io.read())
    if daynumber < 1 or daynumber > 7 then
        print "Where do you live?!"
    else
        print "It is" .. name[daynumber]
    end
end

But this is not the same as a SELECT block.

[kreezxil]

Sweet holy Jesus found this great article on how to implement SELECT CASE into lua and from what I know I can do with LUA in CC 1.53, this can be done. http://dev.oz-apps.com/?p=265

[Kingdaro]

To answer the OP's question, no, there isn't. Either use elseifs, or find another, more efficient way to implement your solution.

---

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
    print "What day is it?"
    daynumber = tonumber(io.read())
    if daynumber < 1 or daynumber > 7 then
        print "Where do you live?!"
    else
        print "It is" .. name[daynumber] --# this line would error.
    end
end

Dropping parentheses only works if you have a single, solitary literal string.

[BigTwisty]

6 lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
    print "What day is it?"
    day = name[tonumber(io.read())]
    print(day and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

[Dave-ee Jones]

BigTwisty, on 21 September 2013 - 10:37 PM, said:

6 lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	day = name[tonumber(io.read())]
	print(day and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

Lol. Nice try but you have to set the day variable, so it won't ever say "Where do you live?!". Nice try tho.

[BigTwisty]

AutoLocK, on 22 September 2013 - 02:27 AM, said:

BigTwisty, on 21 September 2013 - 10:37 PM, said:

6 lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday", "Tuesday", "Wednesday", "Thursday", "Friday", "Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	day = name[tonumber(io.read())]
	print(day and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

Lol. Nice try but you have to set the day variable, so it won't ever say "Where do you live?!". Nice try tho.

I do! On line 4, day is either set to the string for the current day or nil if the day number is out of bounds. Try it, it will work.

[kreezxil]

-- snip --
worthless rewrite removed
-- snip --

Also based on that article I linked:

Spoiler

local coffee = 0
local sheet = {}

function Sunday()
	print "Glory to the King!"
end

function Monday()
	print "Oh crap! It's Monday, how many cups of coffee do you want to drink?"
	coffee=tonumber(io.read())
	if coffee > 3 then
	   print "Oh dear! What did you do last night!"
	else
	   print "Have a great day!"
	end
end

function Tuesday()
	print "Aren't you glad you survived Monday!"
	coffee = coffee - 5
end

function Wednesday()
   print "Have you checked the computer craft forums for in any responses to threads you've participated in? .... Hmmm...."
end

function Thursday()
   -- crunch time, gotta finish the spread sheet
  print "With all of this coffee you had all week, hopefully you can input 10 number right quick!"
  for i=1,10 do
	 print "#"
	 sheet[1]=tonumber(io.read())
  end
  print "Great maybe the boss will give you a break, after all tomorrow is Friday!"
end

function Friday()
  -- You are burnt out from the week's work
  -- you can't think of anything to do except
  local planAParty = true
end

function Saturday()
   if planAParty and coffee > 5 then
	  print "Due to the weekly stress you have decided to throw that party after all and invite all of your friends over!"
   else
	  print "It's been a good week and you want to spend the weekend casually alone with friends."
   end
   planAParty = false
end

function defaultFunc()
   print "What planet do you live on?!"
end

local name = { Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday }

function Select(case)
   func = name[case]
   if func ~= nil then
	  func()
   else
	  defaultFunc()
	  return false
   end
   return true
end

while true do
   print "What day is it? "
   day=io.read()
   local result=select(day)
   if not result then
	  return
   end
end

Considering how hard that is, I think "if then elseif else end" is far simpler, however this probably has its merits too. I am willing to bet one of the pros could easily mod the above to be far more efficient and reusable (generic) than it is now.

Edited by kreezxil, 22 September 2013 - 08:49 AM.

[Shefla]

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	print(name[tonumber(io.read())] and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

It seems the day variable in this version is never initialized.

By the way I think using a table to replicate switch / select is good for simple use cases but it miss break / continue statements and also doesn't let cascade program flow to the next case when not calling break.

[kreezxil]

Shefla, on 22 September 2013 - 08:34 AM, said:

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	print(name[tonumber(io.read())] and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

It seems the day variable in this version is never initialized.

Your're right, I it's total garbage and can't be done the way I wrote it. Day must be captured as a variable before being processed inside the print string.

[BigTwisty]

kreezxil, on 22 September 2013 - 08:48 AM, said:

Shefla, on 22 September 2013 - 08:34 AM, said:

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
while true do
	print "What day is it?"
	print(name[tonumber(io.read())] and "It is "..day or "Where do you live?!")
end

It seems the day variable in this version is never initialized.

Your're right, I it's total garbage and can't be done the way I wrote it. Day must be captured as a variable before being processed inside the print string.

Nice try! This approach would work if you didn't have to print "It is " before the day.

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
while true do
	print("What day is it?  ", name[tonumber(io.read())] or "Where do you live?!")
end

[kreezxil]

What about this at 3 lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
function getDay() day=name[tonumber(io.read())] if day ~=nil then print ("It is " .. day) end return day end
while true do print ("What day is it? (1-7) ",getDay() or "Where do you live?!") end

[ElvishJerricco]

So I think the underlying point everyone's trying to make here is the same one the creators of Lua believe in: Lua doesn't need select case (or switch case, as it is called in most languages). Lookup tables, functions as values, and if/elseif things are more than enough to do it; possibly more compactly, but definitely in a more Lua-like style.

[BigTwisty]

kreezxil, on 22 September 2013 - 12:22 PM, said:

What about this at 3 lines!

name = {"Sunday","Monday","Tuesday","Wednesday","Thursday","Friday","Saturday"}
function getDay() day=name[tonumber(io.read())] if day ~=nil then print ("It is " .. day) end return day end
while true do print ("What day is it? (1-7) ",getDay() or "Where do you live?!") end

Now you're just cheating. You're just stringing statements together. If you do that, you might as well just put it all on 1 line. Your code is actually quite a step back with respect to efficiency.

The point was to reduce the number of function calls as far as possible to show how little Lua actually needs select case statements. I think we've proven our point.

(I still think my coded was the smallest, though...)

[kreezxil]

I don't see anywhere in this thread where readability was stated as a rule. But I'll give you the point. In fact I thought it was Select Case, did you have any comments on the article I found and my implementation of it?